If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, we may receive an affiliate commission. Learn more about our policies and reviews.
Are you tired of your boring, black pumps? Do you want to spice up your wardrobe with a little bit of color and pizzazz? Then, Mary Jane flats are perfect for you! Whether you’re headed to work, school or just out running errands, these classic flats are the most stylish and versatile shoes a woman can own. From casual styles to dressy looks, these flats can take you anywhere — and they won't let you down! You can choose from beige-colored floral flats for a fun look or one with gold accents to add bling to your otherwise casual outfit. But the number of choices available can confuse you. That's why we’ve curated a list of some of the highest-rated Mary Jane flats of 2024, so you can get a pair for yourself without much hassle.
Detailing the Top Mary Jane Flat of 2024
CLARKS Mary Jane Flats — Best Overall
The Clarks Mary Jane flats are a modern take on the classic style, with a sleek finish and one-of-a-kind design. These flats are constructed with a 100% breathable fabric to keep your feet sweat-free. Their removable ortholite footbed and cushion soft technology make them ultra comfortable to wear every day.
The flexible EVA outsole of these flats provides maximum traction and shock absorption on bumpy roads. These Mary Janes boast the just right heel height that is suitable for walking comfortably without having to worry about rolling an ankle. They're also easy to slip on and off. Plus, they are available in four different colors, including navy blue, rose pink, classic black, and dusty brown. The Clarks Mary Jane flats are a perfect combination of both comfort and style, making them the best choice.
Pros
- Stretch fabric panels for enhanced mobility
- Has a removable ortholite foodbed for cushioning
Cons
- Might require regular cleaning
Propet Mary Jane Flats — Water-Resistant
These Mary Jane flats from Propet will be your new go-to for everyday use. These are made with 100% mesh, so they're breathable, comfortable, and offer great support. Their rubber sole makes them durable, while the removable footbed means you can wear them all day long without getting blisters or sore feet. Also, these classic shoes feature a stretchy asymmetric Mary Jane strap with a hook-and-loop closure, so you don't have to worry about falling out of your shoes with the slightest bump on the road.
Plus, they are treated with 3M Scotchgard, making them stain and water resistant. These shoes are available in six different colors so you can easily choose one to spice up your dull casual outfit!
Pros
- Perforated fabric for maximum breathability
- Thick cushioned insoles for pillow-soft comfort
- Durable and lightweight material
Cons
- Some may find the strap closure cumbersome
Dansko Mary Jane Flats — Most Durable
Dansko Mary Jane flats are designed to give your outfit an edgy vibe while still being casual enough for everyday use. Crafted with 100% leather uppers and a rubber sole, they will last a lifetime. They have textile linings and ample cushioning to ensure that you can wear them for hours without worrying about stinky or sweaty feet. The removable, molded EVA footbed with optimal arch support ensures that your feet will be comfortable.
Unlike other uncomfortable shoes on the market, they have an integrated insole with a tuckboard and shank, which enhance stability and help keep your feet aligned. Available in four colors, these flats are a great addition to your wardrobe!
Pros
- Offers optimal arch support to prevent foot ache
- 100% leather upper makes it more durable
- Can be cleaned easily with a soft, dry cloth
Cons
- The leather might crack in hot weather
Comfortview Mary Jane Flats — Vegan Friendly
The Comfortview Mary Jane flats are the perfect blend of comfort and style. Their faux leather upper lends these shoes a streamlined and stylish design, so you can wear them with both jeans and skirts. They feature a self-adhesive strap that provides a secure fit without cutting into your foot. These flats have padded cup insoles that cradle your feet in softness. And the flexible outsole gives you maximum traction on slippery surfaces — perfect for walking around town or running errands.
Plus, they come in three basic colors: navy, brown and black. So, you can get one pair for work and an another pair for your night out with girls. The best part? They’re available in 30 sizes, so no matter what size shoe you wear, there's one that will fit you like a glove!
Pros
- Stable heel technology for utmost comfort and stability
- Faux leather construction makes it vegan-friendly
- 30 sizes available
Cons
- Some may find the high arch irritating
Ollio Mary Jane Flats — Budget-Friendly
These flats are made from a faux suede material, which has a beautiful texture and a rich sheen. The buckle on the top of these Mary Janes is a cute style detail, and the rubber sole of these flats provides enough traction, so you can wear them with confidence no matter where your day takes you. As an added bonus, their man-made material makes them perfect for all kinds of weather — be it winters or rain!
These shoes are available in eleven unique colors. If you like something subtle like burgundy, trendy like lilac or bold like leopard print, there is something for everyone. With such an economical price point, the Ollio Mary Jane flats are the perfect choice for anyone who's on a budget.
Pros
- Can be used as ballet shoes
- Most color and print options
- Has a buckle instead of velcro
Cons
- Don't come with cushioned insoles
Buying Guide: Mary Jane Flats
When you think of Mary Jane flats, you may picture a pair of black shoes with straps and a sturdy sole. These shoes are timeless, but they come in many different styles and colors. If you're looking for some new Mary Janes, then this buyer's guide will help you find the perfect pair.
What to Look for While Buying Mary Jane Flats?
Material
Mary Janes come in a variety of materials, including leather, suede, canvas, and synthetic leather. Leather and suede are known for their sturdiness and flexibility, but suede can easily get stained, thus requiring frequent cleaning.
Canvas Mary Janes are popular among people who want a comfortable shoe that is easy to maintain. If you want something low maintenance, breathable and affordable then go with one made of synthetic leather.
Comfort
Just like other shoes, Mary Janes should be comfortable enough to wear all day without causing any pain or blisters. If you plan on wearing these shoes often during your day-to-day activities, look for shoes that offer maximum comfort without sacrificing style or fashion sense. They should be equipped with a breathable lining and soft insoles.
Also, make sure the shoe fits properly — if your toes hit the front of the shoe when walking or standing up straight, it's too small; if there's extra room inside that causes your foot to move around too much when you walk or run, then it's too big (although this problem can sometimes be fixed by wearing thin socks).
Colors
From bold burgundy to subtle beige, these shoes are available in a range of colors. Before buying, think about what color(s) would best suit your personal style — do you want something that adds a pop of color to your outfit or something subtle that goes with everything in your wardrobe? There are plenty of different colors out there so don't be afraid to experiment with different shades until you find something that suits both your personality and wardrobe needs!
Buckles
The closure on your Mary Jane flats is important because it dictates how easy it is to put on and take off your shoes. The most common types of closures include laces, buckles, and velcro straps. Laces are the most traditional way of securing Mary Jane flats around your foot and ankle, but they can get tangled easily if you're not careful when putting them on or taking them off.
Buckles are good because they allow you to adjust the tightness around the ankle area depending on how loose or tight you want them to be. If you have trouble bending over, then Velcro closures might be a better option for you since they are easier to take on and off than others.
Sole
Depending on the style of shoe and your personal preference, you'll have options like leather soles or rubber soles. Rubber soles are more durable and less likely to scuff or mark up floors. Ideally, it should be slip-resistant and should provide good traction on bumpy terrain so you can wear them in any weather without worrying about slips and falls.
